Friday, December 11, 2009

Faculty Plenary Meeting, Dec. 10, 2009

Date: Tue, 01 Dec 2009 14:21:26 -0600
From: Duane Windsor
To: SEN-FAC@rice.edu
Subject: Senate notice (faculty plenary meeting; faculty survey; information links)

Dear Faculty Colleagues,

A petitioned special plenary meeting of the faculty is now scheduled for December 10 (3-5 pm) in McMurtry Auditorium (Duncan Hall). Information concerning order of business will be sent out as soon as finalized.

Various non-confidential documents or links concerning the potential merger can be found at three websites:

http://www.cs.rice.edu/~vardi/rice/ [you must be on campus to access]

http://staff.rice.edu/staff/RiceBaylor_Home.asp

http://preparingfuturefacultyatrice.blogspot.com/2009/10/links-on-proposed-ricebaylor-merger.html

Duane Windsor
Speaker, Faculty Senate





Friday, October 23, 2009

A Public Lecture on October 26, 2009

Public Lecture (Open to faculty, students, and the general public)

The Whole May Be Less than the Sum of the Parts:
A Personal Perspective on the Rice-BCM Merger

Moshe Y. Vardi
Rice University

McMurtry Auditorium, Duncan Hall, Rice University
October 26, 2009, 4-5:30pm
Map: www.rice.edu/maps
Parking: http://parking.rice.edu/visitors.cfm
Overflow room: Duncan Hall 1064
Webcast: http://webcast.rice.edu/webcast.php?action=details&event=2048

Abstract: Rice University has been engaged since August 2008 in intense negotiations with Baylor College of Medicine (BCM) over a possible merger, motivated by the argument that such a merger "could produce many academic and scientific benefits" for both institutions. A Sept. 25, 2009, joint press release said that "We will work hard to bring our discussions to a successful conclusion over the next four months." In this talk, the speaker will offer his own analysis of the merger proposal, based on publicly available information.

Bio: Vardi is the George Professor in Computational Engineering and Director of the Ken Kennedy Institute for Information Technology Institute at Rice University. He is the co-recipient of three IBM Outstanding Innovation Awards, the ACM SIGACT Goedel Prize, the ACM Kanellakis Award, the ACM SIGMOD Codd Award, and the Blaise Pascal Medal. He is the author and co-author of over 350 technical papers, as well as two books: "Reasoning about Knowledge" and "Finite Model Theory and Its Applications". He is a Fellow of the Association for Computing Machinery, the American Association for Artificial Intelligence, the American Association for the Advancement of Science, and the Institute for Electrical and Electronic Engineers. He is a member of the US National Academy of Engineering, the European Academy of Science, and Academia Europaea. He holds honorary doctorates from the Saarland University in Germany and Orleans University in France.

Monday, September 7, 2009

Faculty Meeting on August 28, 2009

Date: Tue, 25 Aug 2009 08:14:05 -0500
From: Duane Windsor
To: PRES-FAC@rice.edu
Subject: [PRES-FAC] reminder (upcoming faculty meeting - August 28)

Dear colleagues,

I am sending this reminder message that on Friday, August 28, noon-2 pm, I have scheduled a faculty meeting to hear an interim report from the Faculty Merger Review Committee (FMRC), chaired by Professor Don Morrison. The meeting will occur in McMurtry Auditorium (Duncan Hall).

The sole purpose of the meeting being called by the Speaker is to hear the interim report. (The FMRC has not completed its work and there is not yet a final report. The spring resolution establishing FMRC requires some faculty meeting to hear a report not later than early fall. So in consultation with Professor Morrison, I have established this meeting date.) The business of
the meeting will be focused solely on discussion of the interim report.

You are encouraged to attend if your schedule permits to hear this interim report.

Duane Windsor, Speaker, Faculty Senate

Friday, April 10, 2009

A Special Faculty Meeting

Over 60 faculty members signed the following petition, which would result in a special faculty meeting being convened.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rice is contemplating a merger with Baylor College of Medicine, in what may be the most important decision in our institution's history.

When the Faculty Senate was formed, a provision was made for the full faculty to meet whenever events warrant it, upon the collection of 50 faculty signatures. In that spirit, we call for a meeting of the full faculty to discuss this merger and to air both our aspirations and our concerns.

Thursday, March 26, 2009

The MOU

The announcement of the MOU has moved Rice and Baylor closer to the expected merger. Here is the text of the announcement.

March 26, 2009

To the faculties, staffs and students of Rice University and Baylor College of Medicine:

We are pleased to announce that the governing boards of Rice and BCM this week approved the signing of a memorandum of understanding (MOU) that lays out a broad framework for formal negotiations about a possible merger of our two institutions.

While no decision on a merger has yet been made and many issues remain to be resolved, our boards have concluded that a closer affiliation has abundant potential benefits for both institutions, as well as for our home city of Houston. Months of informal discussions have confirmed that the missions and aspirations of our two institutions are in fact closely aligned, that both institutions would benefit in many ways from a merger and that, together, Rice and BCM could be one of the world's leading research universities.

The MOU framework will allow us to systematically and thoroughly move ahead with the next stage of discussions. Over the next few months, we will seek to address issues and concerns that have surfaced from those discussions, and we will continue to solicit input from members of our respective communities. The success of a merger, or any closer affiliation, will also depend significantly on how effectively we plan for and manage its implementation.

Baylor College of Medicine and Rice University are institutions of distinction that bring great achievements and greater potential to such a merger. Each is known throughout the world for contributions to important areas of human knowledge and service. Both are entering this conversation closely attentive to the importance of sustaining that which is great, inspired by the possibilities of expanded distinction and contribution, respectful of our values and traditions, and committed to our responsibilities to Houston and the broader society.

Thank you for the suggestions and insights that have helped shape our discussions so far. We continue to welcome your ideas going forward.

David W. Leebron William T. Butler, M.D.

President Interim President

Rice University Baylor College of Medicine

Monday, February 23, 2009

Rice-BCM Merger: Benefits vs. Risks

As with all actions, one has to weigh the risks vs the benefits. The academic benefits to Rice and BCM of a merger have been discussed for ages. It is an open secret that BCM has been courting Rice for years, and Rice always has shyed of such a merger. BCM's recent financial implosion shows that previous administrations at Rice were right to avoid merging Rice and BCM. The current administration, however, seems quite enthusiastic about the merger. There has been a lot of recent internal communication about the merger, but its seems that the President and Provost of Rice have already made up their mind in favor of the merger, as they always minimize the risks and hype the benefits.

The clearet point in favor of the merger is that Rice would improve its standing in the ranking game and may move up in ranking. I'd be curious to hear what Rice faculty members think of this argument. Will the increase in size move Rice up in ranking? Is this important? Universities often denigrate rankings, while paying close attention to them. Should a merger with BCM be planned based on projected rise in ranking?

Rice Faculty Member

Sunday, February 22, 2009

Rice-BCM Merger

The purpose of this blog is to provide a public forum for Rice and BCM faculty members to discuss the proposed merger between Rice University and Baylor College of Medicine (BCM). The article below provides some basic background. All readers can comment on the postings of this blog. Only Rice and BCM faculty members can post on this blog. To be authorized to blog, send a request to riceufaculty@gmail.com.

Rice, Baylor Medicine closer to merger deal

Institutions just a couple months from a decision

By TODD ACKERMAN

Nov. 11, 2008

Characterizing merger talks with Baylor College of Medicine as serious, Rice University President David Leebron said Tuesday the two elite institutions should know within a couple of months whether such a deal is possible.

Leebron, who just two weeks ago termed discussions preliminary, said the process is moving ahead and generating a lot of enthusiasm but added that a series of practical problems need to be ironed out before Rice and Baylor can be brought together.

"A general prerequisite is that we're sure the medical school would be on stable and secure financial footing and that we continue to see possibilities not just for Baylor to become part of Rice but to build on the synergies that exist between the institutions," said Leebron.

He said the matter will be resolved one way or another this academic year. He said it was "not some general meandering discussion."

The comments, made to the Chronicle editorial board, marked the first time a Rice or Baylor administrator has talked substantively about the possible merger since the Chronicle published an article about it two weeks ago. At the time, Rice and Baylor issued a statement acknowledging preliminary talks but providing no details.

Rice and Baylor have had talks in the past in which the prospect of a merger came up, but they've never reached a serious stage. Such a merger would bring Rice the reputational enhancement it has long desired and Baylor the security of a university affiliation, which is often necessary to keep medical schools afloat financially.

Baylor, which severed ties with the Baptist university of the same name in Waco in 1969, is one of only 10 free-standing medical schools in the United States.

Rice would certainly give Baylor financial security. As of June 30, its endowment was $4.6 billion. As of Sept. 30, Baylor's was $954 million.

The disparity has caused some to question whether Baylor would drain Rice resources — one professor has remarked on the need to build a firewall between the two endowments — but Leebron downplayed the nearly five-fold difference. He said an endowment of about $1 billion is typical of a high-quality medical school.

But Leebron said the big question is how all the parts of the medical school — such as the hospital and clinic it is building — would fit into Rice's overall finances. He called medical schools "extremely complicated" and said the challenge will be "to organize Baylor in a way that fits both the needs of Rice and Baylor."

But Leebron also waxed enthusiastic about the proposed merger, saying that if it can be pulled off, the biggest winner would be the city of Houston.

"To have a top-ranked university and medical school that would attract companies in the area of (pharmaceuticals) and other areas would be a great addition to the city," Leebron said.

He said the reaction to the proposed merger has been positive, from institutions in the medical center to alumni to faculty across the curriculum, not just in the sciences. He said 80 percent of alumni feedback in the past two weeks has been in favor of a merger.

Though Leebron said a medical school is attractive to Rice, he added that the university is only interested in one through a merger with Baylor. Rice is "not in the market for a medical school," he said, and starting one from scratch would be "daunting financially and reputationally."

Medical schools are seen as vital to university prestige, because so much basic science funding has shifted from physics to biology. In 2007, Rice received $11 million in funding from the National Institutes of Health. Baylor received $211 million.